Normal bone and joint X‑rays, region by region
You cannot call a bone or joint film abnormal until you know what normal looks like for that joint: which views are standard, which lines should meet, roughly what the normal measurements are, and which normal structures pretend to be fractures. This page works through the shoulder, elbow, wrist and hand, pelvis and hip, knee, ankle and foot in turn. Use it alongside how to read a skeletal X-ray, which gives the general system, and the fracture module for each joint, which shows what goes wrong.
How to use normal comparators
A "normal" film is one where you checked each part on purpose and every check passed. Three habits make that possible:
- Know the standard views. Many fractures show on only one of two views, so each joint has a standard set (listed below). If a standard view is missing, the film is incomplete, not normal.
- Use the lines. Alignment lines such as Shenton's line or the anterior humeral line turn "it looks odd" into a yes-or-no check. Measurements have wide normal ranges, so compare with the other side when in doubt.
- Learn the variants. Growth plates, apophyses, sesamoids, accessory ossicles and nutrient channels all make normal lines and fragments. Knowing where they live, and what their edges look like, prevents most false fracture calls.
Always read the film with the clinical findings: genuine fractures are often accompanied by soft tissue swelling[1]. Scaphoid, hip and Lisfranc injuries can all be invisible on the first film, so a normal radiograph does not always mean no injury[1].
Pearl
Compare with real normal films of the shoulder, elbow, wrist, hand, pelvis, knee, ankle and foot.
Shoulder
Standard views. In trauma: the AP and the lateral "Y" view (the scapula looks like a Y side-on). If the patient can abduct the arm, an axial (axillary) view can replace the Y view[1].
Normal alignment[1]:
- AP: the humeral head and glenoid contours are aligned.
- Y view: the humeral head sits over the glenoid, at the centre of the Y, and lies behind the coracoid process.
- Axial: the glenohumeral joint and the acromioclavicular joint are both aligned.
Anterior dislocation is about 50 times more common than posterior[1], but the posterior one is the trap: on a single AP it can look nearly normal. A widened joint and a "light bulb" humeral head are clues, though any film taken with the arm internally rotated gives a similar head shape[1]. The second view settles it. See shoulder dislocation and shoulder and clavicle fractures.
Pitfall: variants at the shoulder
In a young patient, the growth plates of the proximal humerus and acromion cross the bone as lucent lines and can be mistaken for fractures[1]. In adults, an os acromiale is an acromial ossification centre that never fused with the rest of the acromion[6]. On the axillary view it appears as a separate piece at the tip of the acromion, divided by a gap of even width[6].
Elbow
Standard views. AP and lateral; the lines need a true lateral, because obliquity distorts them[4].
Fat pads. On a normal lateral a thin dark triangle, the anterior fat pad, often lies in front of the distal humerus; this is normal. The posterior fat pad is normally invisible[1]. A raised anterior or any visible posterior fat pad means an effusion. After trauma with no visible fracture, it usually indicates a radial head fracture in adults and a supracondylar fracture in children[1]. In a study of 197 children's elbow films, cited by DeFroda and colleagues, a normal anterior fat pad had a negative predictive value of 98.2% for fracture[4].
Key lines at the elbow
- Anterior humeral line (true lateral): a line along the front of the humeral cortex should pass through the capitellum. Radiology Masterclass describes at least a third of the capitellum in front of it[1]; DeFroda and colleagues, the line crossing the middle third in most normal elbows[4]. It is less reliable under age 5: in one study of normal elbows it fell outside the middle third in a quarter of children under 5, but in none aged 5 or over[4]. A capitellum behind the line suggests an extension-type supracondylar fracture.
- Radiocapitellar line (every view): a line down the centre of the radial neck and shaft should pass through the capitellum on the AP, oblique and lateral views[1][4]. In one study it missed in 8.6% of normal children's elbows, and was more reliable drawn through the radial head[4]. A clear miss suggests radial head dislocation; look for a Monteggia injury.
Children's ossification centres appear in a fixed order, remembered as CRITOE: capitellum, radial head, internal (medial) epicondyle, trochlea, olecranon and external (lateral) epicondyle[1][4]. Ages vary with sex and between children. DeFroda and colleagues describe ossification starting at about 1 year with a new centre appearing roughly every two years[4]; Radiology Masterclass gives the overall window as 6 months to 12 years[1] [VARIES]. The order is what matters: if the trochlea is ossified but no internal epicondyle is visible in its usual place, suspect that the epicondyle has been avulsed[1]. See the paediatric elbow module and elbow fractures.
Wrist and hand
Standard views. Wrist: PA and lateral, adding an oblique and a PA in ulnar deviation when a scaphoid injury is suspected. Hand: PA, oblique and lateral[1].
Normal carpal alignment:
- Gilula's arcs (PA): arc I follows the proximal surfaces of the scaphoid, lunate and triquetrum; arc II follows the distal surfaces of the same three bones; arc III follows the proximal surfaces of the capitate and hamate[2]. Each should be smooth; a step or break should prompt a search for fracture, malalignment or ligament injury there[2].
- Joint spaces (PA): the intercarpal, radiocarpal, distal radioulnar and carpometacarpal spaces should be even and of similar width[1]. Radiology Masterclass treats a scapholunate gap of more than 2 mm, or one obviously wider than the other intercarpal spaces, as a sign of ligament tear, best shown in ulnar deviation[1]. Comparison with the neighbouring joints matters more than one number.
- Lateral: the radius, lunate and capitate should line up, with the capitate sitting in the cup of the lunate. This view is essential for lunate and perilunate dislocation[1].
Key measurements: distal radius
| Measurement | View | Average (range) in O'Malley et al.[3] |
|---|---|---|
| Radial inclination | PA | 23° (13–30°) |
| Radial height | PA | 12 mm (8–18 mm) |
| Volar (palmar) tilt | Lateral | 12° (1–21°) |
The normal ranges are wide [VARIES]; if unsure, compare with the other wrist.
About 30% of scaphoid fractures are not visible on the X-rays taken at the time of injury, so a clinically suspected fracture is treated as one and followed up per local protocol[1]. See distal radius fractures, scaphoid fracture and hand fractures.
Pelvis and hip
Standard views. An AP of the whole pelvis and a lateral of the hip. Assess the whole pelvis, because a pelvic fracture can mimic a hip fracture clinically[1].
Shenton's line is the smooth curve formed by the medial edge of the femoral neck and the inferior edge of the superior pubic ramus. It should be continuous on both sides. A break in the curve is a sign of a femoral neck fracture, but a fracture does not always break it[1], so trace the femoral neck cortex on both views as well. Compare the two sides for symmetry, and check the pubic rami and acetabula while you are there.
Not every hip fracture is visible on the first film. If pain persists, repeat X-ray, CT or MRI may be needed, with particular care in confused patients[1]. See hip fracture and pelvic fractures.
Pitfall
Nutrient vessel channels in the femur appear as thin dark lines that can be mistaken for fractures. They usually run obliquely through the cortex, may have a corticated edge and do not cause any loss of alignment[1].
Knee
Standard views. AP and lateral. After trauma the lateral is taken supine with a horizontal beam, so fluid in the suprapatellar pouch shows. A skyline view is rarely needed in trauma[1].
The lateral is the key view. Normally the quadriceps and patellar tendons are visible and the suprapatellar pouch is a thin band between fat pads above the patella; widening or increased density there suggests an effusion[1]. A lipohaemarthrosis, a layer of fat floating on blood, means fat and blood have leaked from the bone after a fracture. It can be the only sign of a tibial plateau fracture[1].
Key measurement: patellar height
The Insall-Salvati ratio is the length of the patellar tendon divided by the length of the patella, measured on a lateral radiograph with the knee flexed about 30°. A normal ratio is 0.8–1.2; below 0.8 suggests a low-riding patella (patella baja) and above 1.2 a high-riding one (patella alta)[7].
Pitfall: knee variants
Two common variants mimic fractures: the fabella, a sesamoid in the lateral head of gastrocnemius, and the bipartite patella[1]. A bipartite patella occurs in about 2–3% of people, is bilateral in about half, and the separate piece is superolateral in about 75%[6].
See knee fractures and the lower limb quiz.
Ankle
Standard views. AP, usually as a mortise view angled so the fibula does not overlap the joint, and lateral[1].
Normal mortise. The joint between the tibial plafond and talar dome, including the medial and lateral gutters, is evenly spaced all the way round. Trace the talar dome contour, because osteochondral fractures are subtle[1].
Key measurement: medial clear space
The medial clear space is the gap between the medial malleolus and the medial side of the talus. In normal ankles, Gibson and colleagues found a mean on the unstressed mortise view of 3.1 mm (range 1.9–4.2 mm)[5]. Thresholds for abnormal differ [VARIES]: a commonly used definition of instability is a medial clear space of 4 mm or more that is also at least 1 mm wider than the superior clear space[5], while Gibson's group suggest that more than 5 mm on an external rotation stress view should be regarded as unstable, with 4–5 mm needing more evidence of talar shift[5].
An isolated medial malleolus fracture, or a widened mortise with no fibular fracture, should prompt imaging of the proximal fibula (Maisonneuve fracture)[1]. See ankle fractures.
Pitfall: os trigonum
An os trigonum is a small, often triangular ossicle behind the talus, joined to the posterior process by a synchondrosis. It is found in about 7–8% of people[6]. It was historically mistaken for a fracture (the term "Shepherd's fracture" persists)[6].
Foot
Standard views. Dorsoplantar (DP) and oblique views are standard, and a lateral can help[1]. When a Lisfranc injury is suspected, weight-bearing views are recommended, because a non-weight-bearing film may not show the injury[8].
Key alignment: the tarsometatarsal (Lisfranc) joints
- DP (AP) view: the 2nd metatarsal base lines up with the intermediate (middle) cuneiform[1]: its medial margin is in line with the medial edge of the middle cuneiform, and the lateral margin of the 1st metatarsal base in line with the lateral edge of the medial cuneiform[8].
- Oblique view: the 3rd metatarsal lines up with the lateral cuneiform[1], and the medial edge of the 4th metatarsal base lines up with the medial edge of the cuboid[8].
Loss of the 2nd metatarsal to intermediate cuneiform alignment indicates a Lisfranc injury, even when no fracture is visible[1]. A purely ligamentous injury may not displace on the first film, so suspected injuries need clinical and radiological follow-up[1].
Pitfall: foot variants
- 5th metatarsal base apophysis: the normal unfused apophysis runs along the bone with a rounded, corticated edge; a fracture usually runs across it[1].
- Accessory navicular (os naviculare): posteromedial to the navicular. Type 1 is small and rounded, within the tibialis posterior tendon; type 2 is larger, triangular and joined to the navicular by fibrocartilage[6].
- Bipartite sesamoid: the medial sesamoid under the big toe may be in two parts, a common normal variant[1].
See foot fractures.
Telling a variant from a fracture
The same few questions sort most mimics:
| Question | Favours a normal variant | Favours a fracture |
|---|---|---|
| What are the edges like? | Smooth, rounded, with a dense, fully corticated rim[1] | Sharp, angular, no cortex along the fragment edge[1] |
| Which way does the line run? | Along the bone (5th metatarsal apophysis), or obliquely through the cortex (nutrient channel)[1] | Usually across the bone (for example at the 5th metatarsal base)[1] |
| Is alignment preserved? | Yes: nutrient lines and ossicles do not disturb alignment[1] | Step, angulation or a broken line |
| Soft tissues? | Normal | Swelling, effusion, raised fat pads, lipohaemarthrosis |
| Other side? | Often the same on the other side (bipartite patella is bilateral in about half[6]) | Asymmetric |
Ossicles and their soft tissues can themselves be injured and become painful[1], so if the tenderness is exactly over a "variant", mention it. Terms are explained in the glossary.
Red flags: act now
Do not call these films normal
- Humeral head not sitting on the glenoid on either view.
- A visible posterior fat pad or raised anterior fat pad at the elbow after trauma: treat as an occult fracture.
- A radiocapitellar line that clearly misses the capitellum, or a missing internal epicondyle with an ossified trochlea in a child.
- A broken Gilula arc or a capitate that has left the cup of the lunate.
- Persistent hip pain after a fall despite a "normal" hip film: further imaging may be needed.
- A fat-fluid level on a horizontal-beam lateral of the knee.
- A widened medial clear space, or a step at the tarsometatarsal joints.
What to focus on, by role
| Role | Priorities |
|---|---|
| Medical student | Standard views, one alignment line per joint, and the fat pad sign. |
| Nurse / ENP | Check the right views were taken; escalate dislocation, fat pad sign, lipohaemarthrosis and Lisfranc malalignment. A normal scaphoid or hip film does not end the assessment. |
| Junior doctor | Draw the lines on every film, compare sides when unsure, and follow up suspected occult injuries per local protocol. |
| Radiographer | True laterals at elbow and wrist, horizontal-beam lateral for knee trauma, weight-bearing views for suspected Lisfranc injury, and preliminary clinical evaluation that names recognised variants. |
| Advanced / FRCR | Age-dependent paediatric elbow appearances, rarer ossicles and fast normal-or-abnormal calls. Try the upper limb and lower limb quizzes. |
Practise on real limb X-rays →
References
- Lloyd-Jones G. Radiology Masterclass: trauma X-ray tutorials. Upper limb: glenohumeral joint, elbow, wrist, hand. Lower limb: hip, knee, ankle, foot. Fracture mimics.
- Cadogan M, Turley D. Gilula carpal arcs. Life in the Fast Lane (LITFL). litfl.com
- O'Malley MP, Rodner C, Ritting A, et al. Radiographic interpretation of distal radius fractures: visual estimations versus digital measuring techniques. Hand (N Y) 2014;9(4):488–493. doi:10.1007/s11552-014-9666-2
- DeFroda SF, Hansen H, Gil JA, Hawari AH, Cruz AI. Radiographic evaluation of common pediatric elbow injuries. Orthop Rev (Pavia) 2017;9(1):7030. doi:10.4081/or.2017.7030
- Gibson PD, Ippolito JA, Hwang JS, et al. Physiologic widening of the medial clear space: what's normal? J Clin Orthop Trauma 2019;10(Suppl 1):S62–S64. doi:10.1016/j.jcot.2019.04.016
- Vaz A, Trippia CR. Small but troublesome: accessory ossicles with clinical significance. Radiol Bras 2018;51(4):248–256. doi:10.1590/0100-3984.2017.0147
- Barbosa RM, da Silva MV, Macedo CS, Santos CP. Imaging evaluation of patellofemoral joint instability: a review. Knee Surg Relat Res 2023;35(1):7. doi:10.1186/s43019-023-00180-8
- Burroughs KE, Reimer CD, Fields KB. Lisfranc injury of the foot: a commonly missed diagnosis. Am Fam Physician 1998;58(1):118–124. aafp.org
For education only. Not a substitute for a formal report, senior review or your local policy. Never use this page to make decisions about a real patient.