Radiographer commenting was linked to a small rise in image quality
A study published online in Radiography on 15 October 2026 compared limb and pelvis radiographs taken before and after one site introduced a scheme in which radiographers write alerts about abnormal appearances. Images taken under the scheme were rated as slightly better, mainly because of better positioning.
What's new
Under a Radiographer Comment and Alert (RCA) model, the radiographer who takes the image adds a short written alert when they see something abnormal, before the formal report. The authors wanted to know whether working this way also changes the quality of the images themselves.
They took all 117 pelvis, hand, wrist, elbow, knee, ankle and foot examinations that carried a radiographer comment over 12 months at one site, and matched them with 117 similar examinations from a year before the scheme began. Seventeen radiographers rated the image pairs side by side, shown in random order and left-right position, on seven criteria: rotation, angulation, centring, collimation, exposure, artefacts and diagnostic usefulness.
Overall, the post-scheme images were rated higher, but the difference was small: the area under the visual grading curve was 0.52, where 0.50 would mean no difference (p = 0.016). The gain was clearest for the axial region (0.54) and for rotation (0.57). It did not reach significance for the upper limb (0.52) or lower limb (0.50) on their own. Agreement between the raters was good to excellent.
This is a before-and-after comparison at a single site, so other changes over the same period (staff, equipment, training) could explain part of the difference, and the images with comments were, by design, ones where something abnormal had been seen. Our summary is based on the published abstract.
What it means for learners
- Looking for findings may make you a better image-taker. The authors suggest that radiographers who know they will comment look harder at their own images. Whatever the reason, the gain was mostly in positioning, especially rotation, which is the first check in RIPE for image quality and applies to limbs as well as the chest.
- Quality is part of interpretation. A rotated or poorly centred film can hide or mimic a fracture. The adequacy checks in how to read a skeletal X-ray come before any search for findings.
- A comment is not a report. Radiographer comments and preliminary clinical evaluations support the formal report; they do not replace it. Follow your local scheme and its training requirements.
Source
- Tonks A, Gray F, Nocum D, Jimenez Y, Tavakoli Taba A, Ekpo E. X-ray image quality before and after radiographer commenting: a quantitative visual grading characteristics analysis. Radiography. 2026;32(8):103587. Published online 15 October 2026. doi:10.1016/j.radi.2026.103587 (single-site retrospective before-and-after comparison, 234 radiographs, 17 raters; summary based on the published abstract).
Also in What's new: Why radiographers stop checking an image too soon · Ultra-low-dose pre-shots and wrist X-ray retakes · Radiography students' image interpretation in Ghana.
For education only. Not a substitute for a formal report, senior review or your local policy. Never use this page to make decisions about a real patient.