Ankle decision rules at nurse triage halved X‑ray requests in children

A before-and-after study in the November 2026 issue of the Journal of Emergency Nursing reports that when triage nurses and doctors in a Spanish emergency department applied two clinical decision rules to children with ankle injuries, requests for ankle X-rays fell by about half.

What's new

Most ankle injuries in children are not fractures, yet many are X-rayed. The team introduced a protocol built on the Ottawa Ankle Rules and the Low-Risk Ankle Rule, applied first at nursing triage and then at medical assessment. They compared children aged 3 to 16 seen before the protocol (132) with those seen after it (120).

The proportion of children having an X-ray requested fell by an absolute 46.8 percentage points (a relative fall of about 52%). Put another way, applying the protocol to two children avoided one X-ray request. Agreement between nurses and doctors applying each rule was good to very good (kappa 0.78 for the Ottawa rules and 0.83 for the Low-Risk Ankle Rule). The authors also report shorter stays in the department and cost savings.

The groups were not randomised or matched, and the study was small and in one setting. The authors conclude the approach did not compromise safety, but the abstract does not report how many fractures were found or missed in each group, so this summary cannot confirm that point. Our summary is based on the published abstract.

What it means for learners

  • The best X-ray can be the one not taken. Decision rules exist to avoid radiographs that will not change management, which saves dose and time. Learn the Ottawa rules exactly, including palpating the posterior edge of each malleolus: see clinical decision rules for X-ray and ankle fractures.
  • Check which ages a rule covers. This study included children from age 3, but in the UK NICE NG38 recommends the Ottawa ankle and foot rules for people over 5. Follow national guidance and your local protocol rather than a single study.
  • Children are not small adults. When a child's ankle is X-rayed, look carefully at the growth plate; see Salter-Harris fractures. Every avoided film also counts towards radiation protection.

Source

  • Gómez Gérez C, Hortigüela Aparicio M, Cabrerizo Ortiz M, Anchuela Ciruelos P, Perez-Moneo B, Suarez-Cabezas S. Clinical decision rules and reduction of ankle X-rays in pediatric population: an intervention study. J Emerg Nurs. 2026;52(6):1390–1398. November 2026 issue. doi:10.1016/j.jen.2026.06.020 (quasi-experimental before-and-after study with non-equivalent groups, 252 children, single country; summary based on the published abstract).

Also in What's new: UKHSA X-ray dose tables update · Ultra-low-dose pre-shots and wrist retakes.

For education only. Not a substitute for a formal report, senior review or your local policy. Never use this page to make decisions about a real patient.