Supine chest X‑ray (and the deep sulcus sign)

A supine chest X-ray is taken with the patient lying on their back, usually as an AP (anteroposterior) film from a mobile machine. It is the everyday film on intensive care and in the resuscitation room. Lying flat changes where gravity sends air and fluid, so the textbook signs you learned on the erect PA film can be missing: a pneumothorax may have no visible pleural edge, an effusion may have no meniscus, and the heart and mediastinum look larger than they really are. This module shows you how to read the film the patient actually has, including the deep sulcus sign.

1. Why films are taken supine

The reference chest film is a PA projection: the patient stands facing the detector and the beam passes from back to front. That needs a patient who can stand or sit upright and hold still. When the patient is immobile or seriously ill, the film is taken AP instead, with the detector behind the back, and the patient may be sitting up or lying flat (Kasznia-Brown and Cook, 2006). Typical situations are:

  • Intensive care and high-dependency units, where sedated and ventilated patients are imaged in bed, very often to check tubes and lines.
  • Major trauma, where the patient cannot be sat up until injuries are excluded. See chest trauma X-ray.
  • Any acutely unwell patient who cannot safely be moved into an upright position.

The mobile film does its main jobs well: it shows obvious abnormalities and the position of drains, lines and tubes. Its weakness is fine detail. Kasznia-Brown and Cook note that the lower-energy beam used for portable films limits assessment of the lung, particularly where the chest is thickest.

2. Recognising a supine AP film

You cannot interpret the film until you know how it was taken, so make this part of your pre-checks (see how to read a chest X-ray).

  • The label. The projection should be marked on the image (Kasznia-Brown and Cook, 2006). Look for "AP", "supine", "semi-erect", "sitting" or "mobile". If there is no marker, do not guess.
  • The scapulae. For a PA film the arms are brought forward so the shoulder blades swing out to the sides. On an AP film they stay over the upper lungs (Radiology Masterclass).
  • The context. ECG electrodes, an endotracheal tube, a central line or a nasogastric tube all point to a bed-bound patient. If you are unsure whether the patient was flat or propped up, check the request or ask the radiographer.

AP does not automatically mean supine: many AP films are taken sitting or semi-erect, and the angle of the patient decides where air and fluid settle. When you present the film, say what you think the position was ("AP supine", "AP semi-erect"). How views are named, including horizontal-beam and decubitus views, is covered in X-ray projections.

3. What lying flat changes

FeatureOn a supine AP filmReason
Heart sizeLooks bigger; the cardiothoracic ratio is unreliable.The heart lies at the front of the chest, so on an AP film it is further from the detector and magnified. The shorter tube-to-patient distance of mobile films adds more magnification through a more divergent beam (Radiology Masterclass).
MediastinumLooks wider, occasionally enough to suggest a mass.Kasznia-Brown and Cook illustrate one patient whose mediastinum widens step by step from PA to AP to AP supine.
Hila and upper zone vesselsHila look more prominent; upper lobe vessels look dilated.This is an effect of the supine position, not by itself a sign of heart failure (Kasznia-Brown and Cook, 2006).
Pleural airGathers at the front and the base, not the apex.The anteromedial pleural space is the least dependent part of the chest when the patient lies flat (Sakai et al., 2020).
Pleural fluidLayers behind the lung as a diffuse haze rather than forming a meniscus.Fluid runs to the most dependent, posterior part of the pleural space (Woodring, 1984).

Pearl: heart size works one way only

Because an AP film can only exaggerate heart size, a heart that looks normal on it can fairly be called not enlarged, but a heart that looks large cannot be called enlarged on that film alone (Radiology Masterclass). Comparing with previous films is probably more useful than the cardiothoracic ratio (Kasznia-Brown and Cook, 2006).

Because the supine vascular pattern overlaps with early heart failure, judge fluid status on the whole picture: septal lines, perihilar haze, effusions, the clinical state and the change from earlier films. See heart failure and pulmonary oedema.

4. Pneumothorax on a supine film

On an erect film, pleural air rises to the apex and you look for a thin visceral pleural line with no lung markings beyond it (see pneumothorax X-ray). When the patient lies flat, the highest parts of the pleural space are at the front of the chest and over the diaphragm. Air collects there first, and because the beam passes through that layer face-on, there is often no pleural edge to see.

Where the air goes

In a series of 112 pneumothoraces in 88 critically ill adults filmed supine or semi-recumbent, the anteromedial recess (38%) and the subpulmonic recess under the lung (26%) were the commonest sites (Tocino et al., 1985, abstract). A later review cites the same study with different figures: anteromedial 44%, subpulmonary 29%, apicolateral 13% and posteromedial 13% of 68 supine ICU cases (Sakai et al., 2020) [VARIES]. Both versions agree on the order: front and base first, while the classic apical pleural line is the minority pattern.

Signs to look for

  • Deep sulcus sign. Air in the lateral part of the space under the lung makes the lateral costophrenic angle abnormally deep and lucent on the affected side. Gordon (1980) described seven cases in which this was the only sign of pneumothorax on a supine film. Compare the two costophrenic angles: asymmetry is the clue.
  • Unusually crisp heart border and diaphragm. Air in the anteromedial space below the hilum sharpens the heart border, the inferior vena cava and the pericardial fat pad, and can deepen the anterior cardiophrenic angle. Above the hilum it can sharpen the superior vena cava on the right and the left subclavian artery on the left (Sakai et al., 2020).
  • A darker hemithorax or upper abdomen. One lung field may look more lucent than the other, sometimes as a rounded or oval lucency. Air beneath the lung can make the upper abdominal quadrant unusually dark and show the underside of the lung (Sakai et al., 2020).
  • Double diaphragm sign. The aerated lung outlines the dome of the diaphragm while pleural air separately outlines the anterior costophrenic angle, giving two diaphragm-like contours on one side (Sakai et al., 2020).
  • Posteromedial air. Less often, usually with lower lobe collapse or other lung disease, a lucent triangle sits beside the lower spine with its apex pointing to the hilum (Sakai et al., 2020).

Pearl: look low before you look high

On a supine film, check the costophrenic angles, the heart borders and the upper abdomen for air before you look at the apices. The subpulmonic signs can only be seen if the image includes the upper abdomen.

Why it matters

Supine pneumothoraces are easily missed. In the Tocino series, 30% were not picked up at first by the clinician or radiologist, and half of those progressed to tension pneumothorax. In trauma, a Cochrane review pooling nine studies (1,271 patients, 410 with pneumothorax) found a summary sensitivity of only 0.47 (95% CI 0.31–0.63) for supine chest radiography, against 0.91 (0.85–0.94) for chest ultrasound performed by front-line non-radiologist doctors; specificity was close to 1 for both (Chan et al., 2020). Put simply, a normal supine film does not exclude a pneumothorax.

5. Pleural effusion on a supine film

On an erect film, fluid settles at the base and blunts the costophrenic angle with a meniscus (see pleural effusion X-ray). When the patient lies flat, free fluid spreads out along the back of the chest. Viewed from the front, that thin sheet looks like a veil: a hazy increase in density over the lower zone or the whole hemithorax, with the lung vessels still visible through it.

Woodring (1984) prospectively studied supine films in 40 patients with effusions and compared them with later erect PA and lateral films. The supine signs he used were:

  • a uniform increase in density over the lung field (the veil),
  • loss of the outline of the hemidiaphragm,
  • a meniscus,
  • apical capping (fluid collecting over the lung apex), and
  • a more prominent minor fissure on the right.

An effusion large enough to blunt the costophrenic angle on an erect PA film (175–525 mL in that study) produced a noticeable increase in lower zone density on the supine film, and the abnormality grew in steps as the volume increased. Haze over the whole hemithorax and apical capping were late findings, typically seen with large effusions. A small effusion may therefore show as nothing more than a slightly greyer lower zone.

Pitfall: one lung greyer than the other

A uniformly greyer hemithorax on a supine film can be a layering effusion, but even slight rotation makes one lung look more lucent than the other (Kasznia-Brown and Cook, 2006). Check rotation first. Then ask whether vessels are still visible through the haze (favouring fluid) or whether there are air bronchograms in a lobar distribution (favouring consolidation; see consolidation).

6. A note on free abdominal gas

The same principle, that gas rises to the least dependent space, applies below the diaphragm. In a supine patient, free intraperitoneal gas gathers under the front of the abdominal wall rather than under the diaphragm, so the crescent you expect on an erect film may be absent. Supine signs of free gas are covered in pneumoperitoneum. Free abdominal gas and pneumomediastinum can also mimic air under the lung (Sakai et al., 2020); see the pitfalls below.

7. What to do next

  • Compare with earlier films, ideally taken in the same position. A newly deep costophrenic angle or a newly sharp heart border is far more convincing than an isolated appearance.
  • Bedside ultrasound is more sensitive than the supine film for traumatic pneumothorax when performed by trained front-line doctors (Chan et al., 2020). It depends on operator skill, and deeper regions of the chest can be hard to see (Sakai et al., 2020). Use it within your local training and governance.
  • CT assesses abnormal air collections more accurately than the radiograph, but transferring a critically ill patient carries its own risks (Sakai et al., 2020). Tocino and colleagues advised active use of additional views, including CT, to improve detection.
  • For a suspected effusion, positioning can help. Möller (1984) found that an oblique semi-supine view showed free fluid as well as the lateral decubitus view, showed loculated (encapsulated) fluid better, and was tolerated by more patients.
  • Follow your department's guidance and the RCR iRefer recommendations on which test to request. In a deteriorating patient the decision is clinical first and radiological second.

8. Pitfalls and mimics

  • Searching only the apex for a pneumothorax. On a supine film, apical air is the less common pattern (Tocino et al., 1985).
  • Calling cardiomegaly or a widened mediastinum on a supine AP film. Both are magnified. Compare with older films, and in trauma follow the trauma imaging pathway rather than a width measurement. See chest trauma X-ray.
  • Diagnosing heart failure from upper lobe vessels. Upper zone vessel prominence is expected in a supine patient (Kasznia-Brown and Cook, 2006).
  • The pericardial fat pad. Outlined by anteromedial air, it can look like a mass or a collapsed segment of lung (Sakai et al., 2020).
  • Missing the effusion. A layering effusion has no meniscus, and a small one may be only a faint lower zone haze (Woodring, 1984).
  • Pneumomediastinum and pneumoperitoneum can mimic subpulmonic pleural air. If air outlines the central part of the diaphragm (the continuous diaphragm sign), think of these rather than a pneumothorax (Sakai et al., 2020). See pneumomediastinum.
  • Lung or pleural disease hiding the pleural line. The visceral pleural line needs aerated lung to be seen, so pneumonia, ARDS, effusion or focal adhesions can hide it even when air is present (Sakai et al., 2020).

Unfamiliar terms are explained in the glossary.

Red flags: act now

Escalate immediately

  • A deep sulcus sign, double diaphragm or unexplained lucent hemithorax in a ventilated or trauma patient: possible pneumothorax, which can enlarge and progress to tension.
  • Features of tension on the film: mediastinal shift away from the affected side, an inverted hemidiaphragm, widened intercostal spaces and, importantly, flattening of the heart border and venae cavae, which reflects impaired venous return (Sakai et al., 2020). Tension is a clinical diagnosis and treatment must not wait for imaging.
  • A new or rapidly increasing haze over one hemithorax after trauma or a procedure: possible haemothorax or large effusion.
  • Any tube, line or drain in an unexpected position. Confirmation of device position must follow local policy.

What to focus on, by role

RolePriorities
Medical studentTell a supine AP film from an erect PA film, explain why the heart looks bigger, and say where air and fluid go when the patient lies flat. Be able to describe the deep sulcus sign.
NurseKnow that a "normal" supine film does not rule out a pneumothorax. Escalate a ventilated or trauma patient who deteriorates, whatever the last film showed.
Junior doctorCheck the bases, heart borders and upper abdomen first on every ICU and trauma film. Document the position the film was taken in, and know when to ask for ultrasound or CT.
RadiographerMark projection and position clearly (supine, semi-erect), include the upper abdomen where local protocol allows, and flag a suspected deep sulcus sign promptly.
Advanced / FRCRThe full set of anteromedial, subpulmonic and posteromedial signs, tension signs on a supine film, and separating subpulmonic air from pneumoperitoneum and pneumomediastinum.

Practise on real chest X-rays →

References

  1. Gordon R. The deep sulcus sign. Radiology 1980;136(1):25–27. doi:10.1148/radiology.136.1.7384513
  2. Tocino IM, Miller MH, Fairfax WR. Distribution of pneumothorax in the supine and semirecumbent critically ill adult. AJR Am J Roentgenol 1985;144(5):901–905. doi:10.2214/ajr.144.5.901
  3. Sakai M, Hiyama T, Kuno H, et al. Thoracic abnormal air collections in patients in the intensive care unit: radiograph findings correlated with CT. Insights Imaging 2020;11:35. doi:10.1186/s13244-020-0838-z (open access)
  4. Woodring JH. Recognition of pleural effusion on supine radiographs: how much fluid is required? AJR Am J Roentgenol 1984;142(1):59–64. doi:10.2214/ajr.142.1.59
  5. Möller A. Pleural effusion: use of the semi-supine position for radiographic detection. Radiology 1984;150(1):245–249. doi:10.1148/radiology.150.1.6359265
  6. Chan KK, Joo DA, McRae AD, et al. Chest ultrasonography versus supine chest radiography for diagnosis of pneumothorax in trauma patients in the emergency department. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2020;7:CD013031. doi:10.1002/14651858.CD013031.pub2
  7. Kasznia-Brown J, Cook C. Evaluation of the chest X-ray: a pictorial review. Br J Hosp Med 2006;67(12):628–633. doi:10.12968/hmed.2006.67.12.22434
  8. Radiology Masterclass. Chest X-ray quality: projection. radiologymasterclass.co.uk

For education only. Not a substitute for a formal report, senior review or your local policy. Never use this page to make decisions about a real patient.