A lower pH cut-off for NG tube checks did not increase X‑ray use in one centre

A single-centre audit published in the British Journal of Nursing on 23 October 2026 reports that adopting a pH of 4.5 or below, rather than the nationally quoted 5.5 or below, to confirm nasogastric (NG) tube position did not lead to more chest X-rays at insertion.

What's new

National guidance in England, dating back to the National Patient Safety Agency, uses a bedside pH test first: an aspirate pH of 5.5 or below suggests the tube is unlikely to be in the lung. The authors note concern that 5.5 is too high a cut-off, and that proposals for a lower threshold have usually been rejected because a stricter test would send more patients for an X-ray.

Their centre introduced a pH 4.5 or below threshold as a patient-safety initiative, and the paper describes snapshot audit data collected between 2018 and 2026. According to the abstract, X-ray use did not rise after the threshold was lowered, and the authors conclude that the change was simple and used equipment and techniques nurses already knew.

This is a single-centre audit, not a trial. The abstract does not give the audit numbers, and we have not been able to read the full text, so we cannot report rates, sample sizes or whether any misplacements were detected or missed. The result may not apply to units with different patients, case mix or policies. The paper does not change national guidance, which uses pH 5.5 or below; follow your local policy.

What it means for learners

  • Know your local threshold. Some trusts may set a stricter pH cut-off than the national one. The number that applies to you is the one in your local NG tube policy, not this page. The national approach is set out in NG tube position on X-ray.
  • The X-ray is the back-up check, so read it properly. Whatever the pH threshold, the film is requested when the bedside test fails or is not possible. All four radiographic criteria must be met, on the current film.
  • pH supports, it does not prove. A low pH has been seen with a tube in the lung, as the 2026 NGPod device withdrawal showed. Escalate any doubt and never use a tube while its position is uncertain.

Source

  • Williams V, Fitzpatrick N, Malhi H, Denner L, Fletcher J. Impact of pH 4.5 cut-off in nasogastric feeding tube confirmation on related X-ray use: single-centre study. British Journal of Nursing. 2026;35(19):S14-S18. Published 23 October 2026. doi:10.12968/bjon.2026.0300 (single-centre audit; summary based on the published abstract).

Also in What's new: MHRA withdraws the NGPod pH device · RCR guidance on AI in reporting workflows.

For education only. Not a substitute for a formal report, senior review or your local policy. Never use this page to make decisions about a real patient.